My earliest memory of door opening etiquette goes back to when I was 12 or so. I was shopping with my mom and she said "girls appreciate it when you open the door for them." That was relatively subtle, I should have known she meant that I should open the door for her and that I should develop the habit of opening doors for all girls, but I just thought to myself, "Mom, you're not a girl, you're a Mom (sorry Mom if you're reading)."
I forgot about door opening for a year or two and then it came up again when I started dating in high school. In high school when I was on a date I'd always feel a bit stupid opening the door for a girl. I wasn't sure if I should open the door when we arrived at the car, but not when we left the car (make her just sit there while I walk around?), if I should open the door every time we entered or just when I picked her up. I really didn't know what to do in a cramped space, I mean, sometimes, like if you're really close to another car or a wall, it's really hard to get in there. In those cases if you want to open the door you gotta squeeze past (when you're bigger) open the door backward, let her in, and then squeeze back out. Now, I know this rarely happens but it
does happen so it's just another thing to account for.
My adolescent brain (granted, my overthinking adolescent brain) finally came up with this rule (which I still stand by): open the door every time she enters the car, but let her leave the car on her own, if it is too awkward to open the door just apologize and let her get it. I settled on this stance cause it seemed pretty stupid to me to make the girl wait for you to walk around so she can get out of the car. I mean, that's not chivalry, that's just inconvenience for everyone. The one great exception to this rule is if you're wearing a tux. If you're wearing a tux it's a highly formal setting and you should walk around (and besides, she's probably wearing something so ungainly that she could use your help).
Now that I knew how to open the door I had to figure out why and when. I never really faced then "when" issue until after my mission.
When I came home from my mission I dated as much as I could (that post-mission dating fervor). I decided then that my door opening policy would be to open car doors for girls I'm attracted to. I reasoned that opening the door for a girl is a romantic gesture, a way of expressing interest, so I'd only open doors when I wanted to express interest. The problem with that is it's misleading. If a guy is a gentlemen only to get a girl's interest, but then discontinues being gentlemen once he wins the girl over, it's really unfair to the girl. It's like selling an inferior product with shiny packaging. So, I decided not to open the car door for girls at all cause I couldn't see myself doing something that inconvenient years down the road (neither can most men...think about it, how many married men open the car door for their wives?).
When I made this decision I felt like a martyr. I knew I'd annoy girls, I knew they'd think I wasn't a gentleman, but deep down I was thinking "at least I'm honest, at least I'm consistent--what you see is what you get." I took this attitude on dates for about a year...eventually a girl complained about it.
After she complained I sat down and thought about reasons to open the door for girls. This is what I came up with:
Initially you open the door for a girl because it is now (regardless of what it used to mean) a social convention used to express respect and gratitude for women. The obvious follow up question to this is "why don't women similarly open doors for men to express respect and gratitude?" My answer to that is that men and women both have social conventions intended to show respect and gratitude for the other gender's company. Men have more direct gestures (such as door opening), women, on the other hand, have more indirect gestures (subtle compliments and such). So, women don't open doors for men because they convey the same message through other means.
Also, one reason for door opening that's often missed is it shows a girl (at some minute level) that you're concerned with her safety. Which, when you think about it, is really important-- a girl going on a date with a guy is showing a large amount of trust. I mean, guys are usually much stronger than girls...if a guy wanted to hurt a girl he could. On a first date the girl doesn't know whether she's on a date with Charles Manson or (now I'm throwing up a little) Edward Cullen. Opening the door for her lets her know that you're trying to care for her...basically putting concerns to rest and placing you on the Edward Cullen side of things.
The final reason to open doors (once in a relationship) is to renew the relationship. Once things get serious you may not feel the freshness and excitement you originally did, but you should
want to feel that way. So, I guess opening the door then becomes something of a ritual of remembrance. I think that thinking about door opening as a ritual is fair because rituals (on the whole) are impractical and often ridiculous practices made significant only because they represent something sacred or significant. Door opening squares nicely with this definition: it is impractical, and often ridiculous, but it signifies something sacred and significant: your relationship. So, simply put, my last reason to open doors is it allows guys to reiterate the importance of, and their commitment to, the relationship.
And now I'll just conclude by saying you should
always open the door for
every girl because, if you agree with the initial purpose of door opening (as a respectful gesture of kindness and caring), to not open the door for a girl is an insult.
Now I'll end this post by sharing the experience that made me think of it writing about door opening in the first place. About three weeks ago I was walking into the BYU library and I tried to hold open the door for the girl behind me. She just stood there annoyed, waiting for me to let it close, so I removed my hand. She then opened the door herself and looked at me like she made some huge point. As she walked through she said "I can get the door for myself thank you very much." I was annoyed (which usually leads to me saying something insulting (in this instance I almost said "I'm sorry sir, I thought you were a woman, I was just trying to be polite"), but I bit my tongue.
Well, I think I better stop now. I can't imagine many people still being interested in something as simple as door opening for as long as I've discussed it. Hope you all have a great day.